Bev’s Imaginary Book Club: City of Girls, Daisy Jones and Six, and Where the Crawdads Sing

I don’t know if this can actually be counted as “book club” since it’s 6:15am and there’s zero rosé involved. One can dream.

Bev's Imaginary Book Club

At last! A post I’ve been promising since the Ice Age. Finally had the chance yesterday to sit down on the dirty floor in the front hallway, rummage through a cramped bookshelf of dusty photo albums and novels I’ve read this year and figure out which three books to incoherently blab about to the Internet slash no one.

I WAS going to talk about Then She Was Gone, but realized my sister-in-law has it in Arkansas. I’ll get it back over Labor Day and get back to you. I’m rightly sure you’ll hold your breath until then.

But the more I thought about it, the more obvious it became that the three above are books that still loom around in my psyche, for any number of reasons. Whether it be me strolling down sunny Sunset Boulevard in Los Angeles, or overhearing a certain word or phrase from the south, or piles of vibrant fabric spotted in a vintage clothing store, these books STAY with me.

So these we shall discuss.

Bev's Imaginary Book Club

I’ll start with the most recent read (well, two books back. yes I’m a maniac.) and we’ll go back in time.

City of Girls, by Elizabeth Gilbert.

Oh my gosh. Oh my ever lovin’ good gracious.

I wasn’t sure I’d like it. I had no idea what to actually expect, other than the, “Yeah yeah it’s set in New York City in 1940 and it’s theater and fashion and sex.”

Well, that it is! But it’s so, so so much more.

A 19-year old Vivian Morris gets sent to New York City (after being kicked out of Vassar, oopsie!) to live with her foot-loose-and-fancy-free Aunt Peg, the co-owner of an almost falling-down rusty theater, called The Lily Playhouse. From there, SO MUCH HAPPENS. Vivian discovers her sexual side (be warned, sensitive readers: it gets, um, descriptively hey-oooooh! at times. You’re like, “OKAY I’M IN”.) She cozies in not only to a few tight female relationships early on, but falls deep into an idolizing obsession over an older woman, a fashion icon in her eyes. (and mine, too if we’re honest).

Vivian (Vee, for short) is a brilliant budding seamstress, and helps bring the theater back to life with her ability to shop for fabric and sew the most outrageous costumes for showgirls and actors.

But she makes a mistake. A horrible, scandalous mistake that sets her back professionally and personally with every single person she knows.

And these are just the young years.

Fast forward through time, as we watch Vivian grow older, escaping an almost-marriage, a move back to New York City, a rebuilding of sorts with her Aunt Peg (Who actually never gave up her. Oh, Aunt Peg!) and beyond. She takes us through the 1950s and ’60s (my favorite part was the visual of Vivian and her lady crew sitting on top of their Manhattan building in the summertime with a fan blowing up their shirts to cool their boobs. I wanna do that!), the financial and emotional remnants of the war, the changing of times, fashion, her FRIENDS.

That’s the best part of the whole ding dang thing. Her lady friends. Her crew. While she did have romantic loves in her life (okay, a sloth of lovers), it’s her female friends that really made up the fabric (ha! oh) of Vivian Morris. And it’s such a freaking delight to read.

Oh! And get this, the whole book is a letter to a woman named Angela, the daughter of a man she once loved. That part’s not exactly scandalous. Just beautiful. Moving.

I’ll be honest, the only other book by Gilbert that I’ve read was (of course) Eat, Pray, Love. And that book swallowed me whole, like every other human on this planet. But you know what, City of Girls is so.much.better.

It’s a breezy read. But gutsy. Lots of dialogue, lots of interesting internal narrative. And beyond that it’s fashion and theater and YOUTH. And New York City! Honestly what’s not to love.

And really, what stands out is the message. The message of not losing yourself in the deluge of what a man expects. The message of standing up for your independence and female strength. For the protection of your army of women friends. Vivian and Aunt Peg (and Olive!) were not only unexpected trendsetters for the time, they were laying the groundwork for what would become the fundamental bed of women’s rights and independence. I could not love it more.

I know I’m forgetting so much, but have you read it? Did you obsess? Who was your favorite character? Tell me your takeaways!

City of Girls, one of THEE BEST books I’ve read this year, and in my entire life.

The end.

Bev's Imaginary Book Club

Daisy Jones and the Six, by Taylor Jenkins Reid.

Oh my gosh. Ohhhh my heart.

First of all, it’s just everything you want in a book, yet you don’t know it.

Another period piece, this tale (and it is a tale! totally fiction. hard to believe, right?!) takes place in the 1970s, Los Angeles. The book is 100% interview style, which at first you’re like, “Am I going to like this? Can I get used to this rhythm, this choppy dialogue?” YES, yes you can, and you will. It’s like watching any E! Hollywood rockumentary. In.

You have a band. A band with a broodingly handsome lead singer named Billy. A band wanting to make it big in the L.A. (and everywhere, duh) scene. And you have a young girl with a tiny waist (I’m fine), unruly red waves and a voice so in charge it runs you over like a semi. Eventually this band and this girl (DAISY JONES, if you haven’t figured that out) come together on what they think will be a fleeting moment of success, with a duet called Honeycomb. Well, it’s more than successful. So beyond successful that Daisy Jones joins the band (against Billy’s bratty tantrum-like will) and things just get so crazy from there.

Magic is made! But at a huge price.

Fame. Sex. Drugs. Touring. Infidelity. Heartbreak. And that’s just the surface.

You basically watch the rising success of this band, with the intoxicating enchantment that is Daisy Jones, and then you watch it completely and painfully crumble right in front of your eyes.

It’s so Fleetwood Mac! Hiiiieeee, Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham. AND CHRISTIE AND JOHN McVIE. Interwebs of passionate crazy town. I think I read that Daisy Jones and the Six fictionally mimics the story of Fleetwood Mac. And I’m here for it.

The story ends in an unexpected, respectful way. Much like City of Girls, there’s a tie from the interviewer to a specific reader recipient. And you do find out that not all musicians are evil horn dogs! (I’ve not said “horn dog” since 1993.)

During the band’s heyday (an iconic era for Rock and Roll, to say the least), they released a record called Aurora. And I desperately need it to be real so that I can listen to it for the rest of ever.

Having music in my blood, and knowing what it’s like (even just a tiny speck) being in bands, this one just spoke to me. I loved the language, the setting, the time period, the clothing, the dynamic, the passion. And I really need Daisy Jones to do my hair.

The end.

(also, should I read The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo? Same author, right?)

Bev's Imaginary Book Club

Last but definitely not least, Where the Crawdads Sing.


Okay, yeah. This book. Wow.

I’m going to go ahead and say this is my favorite book so far of the year. Big words, I know. But it’s just so . . . PERFECT.

Another period book (you see a theme here), it toggles between the years 1952 (and on) and 1969 (and on). An excruciatingly poor six-year old Kya Clark is all but abandoned by her family to survive on her OWN in a tiny shack along the North Carolina marshland. Dude, I read this and tried to imagine Nat and Will having the smarts to be on their own in that sort of climate? No. Guess again. Not happening. Yet you can’t look away.

The whole story is just so beautifully intriguing. Of course there’s a murder. And coming of age. And a young girl on her own figuring out what her body does once a month. I was SO GLAD they didn’t gloss over that. And there’s love. And complex characters, some a product of their time, and others that you fall in love with (oh, Jumpin and Mabel!) And young boys with blond wavy hair. And obviously heartbreak. All the human things that make us weird creatures tick.

Along with that, there’s race. And prejudice and vile judgement. But this is the thing – even with the hard, ugly things to get through, Delia (almost called her Celia! ha. Celia Ray. Get it? Never mind) Owens’ writing is just exquisite. Being a successful nature writer, she brings her gift of imagery to a novel platform, and it just blows you away.

The story is tender, sweet, awful, disgusting, interesting, captivating, and stunning. And then the end. The (ahem) poetic twist at the tail end just makes you sit back with wide eyes and take in what just happened to your whole perspective and psyche and REMNANTS OF EMOTIONAL DESTRUCTION. Never have I experienced such satisfaction at the end of a story.

It’s like, a perfect book.

The end.

Bev's Imaginary Book Club

So, here’s the official list of BEV BOOKS (ha) that we’ve (I’ve) read this year. 20 novels, guys. Kind of into this number. If you want me to review any of these in particular, cast your vote and I’ll try to for next time!

Of course all these abridged recaps (with more spoilers in them) are saved in my Instagram highlights, if you fancy a gander.

(also, how many of these are going to be movies?!)

Bev's Imaginary Book Club

So this is what’s next! I will say, I have about 70 pages left of Something in the Water, so stay tuned for that recap in Stories. (I still owe you Behind Closed Doors, too. hoooooooly nightmares.)

I have a LONG list of books going, but I change my mind on the order so frequent, hence the non-intimidating list of five here. If you have any suggestions of books to add to the master, by all means, HOLLA BACK, BAE. (sorry)

And finally, if you’re into this format, let me know and I’ll keep it an ongoing blog series. Like once every two months or something?

ALSO AND THIS IS COOL so thanks for humoring me. On September 12th, my favorite minimal earthy home boutique Golden and Pine is going to host a book club hang for me! I’ll be announcing the book at the beginning of August (hi, what would we read?) so that you have plenty of time to read it. And then come hang out and drink wine and eat snacks with me. Duh.


, , ,

28 Responses to Bev’s Imaginary Book Club: City of Girls, Daisy Jones and Six, and Where the Crawdads Sing

  1. Nicole July 18, 2019 at 10:11 am #
    Where the crawdads sings is the best book I have read in a long time. Thanks for the suggestion. Just Amazing!!!!! I bet they make into a movie.
  2. Crystal July 18, 2019 at 10:13 am #
    OMG, your reaction to Daisy Jones & the Six is exactly my reaction! That book was everything! I still think about it and wish desperately that it was an actual band so I can hunt them down on Spotify and obsess over them. (Not that I'm NOT doing that right now!) And now I'm going to go since I've abused the exclamation point like the deranged psycho I am!
  3. Jeanette July 18, 2019 at 10:20 am #
    This list is much appreciated! I need a book as of today! I just finished The Tatooist of Aushwitz, such a wonderful read.
    • Jen July 19, 2019 at 2:48 pm #
      The Taooist of Aushwitz was amazing as well as The Nightingale. I am going to start on Where the Crawdads sing ASAP! I love everything about you Bev! Thank you for this wonderful breakdown of these books. 🧡
  4. Emily July 18, 2019 at 10:48 am #
    I must say, I am really enjoying your book updates both in Instagram Stories and here on your blog. I would love to see this series keep going. Thanks Bev!
  5. Ali July 18, 2019 at 11:22 am #
    Oh, I'm so happy to read your thoughts on two of the books I've LOVED this year, Daisy and Crawdads (I'm on the wait list for City of Girls). I just loved them both. The others that I can't quite shake are A Place For Us and Eleanor Oliphant is Completely Fine. Reading/watching your responses to them is such a joy because these books just beg for discussion. Can you imagine the money they'd make if they released the Aurora album? People would go NUTS!
    • Bev Weidner July 18, 2019 at 1:20 pm #
      Ali, yeeeees on Eleanor and Place For Us. Both were incredible. I could yap all day about Oliphant and her quirky nature and odd style. I feel like talking about A Place For Us is harder. It's so deep, and I don't think a lot of people would fall so "in love" with it as other books. But I obsessed. It was hard to read, but so powerful. Thanks for bringing those up! And - dude seriously. If Aurora was real, the world would flip out!
  6. Evelina July 18, 2019 at 11:35 am #
    I read Crawdads and also loved it! The ending was so good but I never wanted the book to finish. This one has been confirmed as a movie coming soon. I'll be reading city of girls next, thanks for the recommendation!
  7. Kimberly July 18, 2019 at 12:47 pm #
    Yes you should absolutely read the Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo!
  8. Kristen July 18, 2019 at 1:18 pm #
    Big YES to Evelyn Hugo. I liked it more than Daisy Jones. Almost a similar feel, but behind the scenes in Hollywood instead of the music industry. I read it over a year ago and still think about it at least once a week.
  9. Ashley July 18, 2019 at 3:03 pm #
    I think you need to read The Most Fun We Ever Had....nothing happens, but EVERYTHING happens!
  10. Sommer July 18, 2019 at 3:04 pm #
    Yes! Keep this series going! Several of my coworkers at work are working through your lists :)
  11. Rachel July 18, 2019 at 4:44 pm #
    Thank you for the suggestions!! I’ll be adding a lot of these to my library list. If you haven’t already, you need to read Ghosted!!! Such a good book with such a huge plot twist.
  12. Joanne H Bruno July 19, 2019 at 5:44 am #
    LOVE this! Please keep the review coming!!! Would totally love if this was a monthly or every-two-monthly feature.
  13. Becky Van Drunen July 19, 2019 at 12:37 pm #
    Just flew through 2 of these 3 over the last month geez louise I just feel so many things. 1st. City of Girls. I have 2 daughters and remember when I was pregnant with my 2nd thinking "omg I love my 1st daughter so much how could I possibly have room for this new baby in my heart"?..." but then (stay with me, I have a point) my heart expanded and if course my love continued for my 1st and I had enough room to love this new baby. This book was THAT for me. Life gives us the love we need in all sorts of people right at the time we need them. Sometimes they stay and sometimes they don't but once we for them we always have room for them. And even when we think our heart is full there is room to keep growing. So cliche. But thats how this makes me feel. Its incredibly comforting. Now. Where the Crawdads Sing. Gah. Your description was spot on. Its the perfect book. When it was over i just stared at the wall. I was ready for it to end and never wanted it to end all at the same time. Perfection. Love this and can't wait to read more of these!
  14. Christie July 19, 2019 at 1:24 pm #
    Please keep the book club posts and ig stories going. I have enjoyed reading my way through the list!
  15. Liz July 20, 2019 at 12:16 pm #
    Love the book club and love your reviews!!! I was so excited to see this post! I really loved all three of these books and also read "A Place for Us" thanks to your recommendation and it's one of the best books I've read in a long time! I was astonished to see how young the author is, she is certainly an old soul. I'm currently reading "Ask Again, Yes" and it is excellent!
  16. Tracy July 20, 2019 at 3:55 pm #
    Absolutely love & appreciate the book club and your reviews here and on IG! Please continue!
  17. Ashton July 22, 2019 at 8:57 am #
    I enjoy your book recommendations! I've read a few of them here in Columbus, OH. Currently reading the Wife Between Us. Thanks for the inspiration!
  18. Jennifer July 23, 2019 at 2:18 pm #
    Another big yes for The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo! Loved that book (and the others you mention here).
  19. brittany July 26, 2019 at 11:51 am #
    I'm late to the party on this post, but you should 1000% read The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo. I read it in a weekend, which is basically unheard of with a toddler, but it was SO GOOD I couldn't put it down.
  20. Brittany July 27, 2019 at 7:06 am #
    I just finished "The Most Fun We Ever Had" by Claire Lombardo and it was incredible. I have read 15 books this summer and that one was easily my favorite. Highly recommend.
  21. Hallie Sawyer August 9, 2019 at 11:16 am #
    I've heard so many good things about all of these books and this post solidifies their spots on my to-read list. And the book club at Golden and Pine sounds like perfection! I'm in.
  22. Mario Fred April 4, 2020 at 12:30 pm #
    I men actually believe that you will need to get acquainted with young women on a wonderful dating website. They will be able to allow you to talk on any topic on the topic of commitment on the topic of the fact that you always wanted to free asian dating sites in usa ask a question. And I suppose you want to introduce a family. This will allow you to more adore and recognize young women. I believe in fact that it will undoubtedly help you to arrange a large amount of love for you
  23. Hares Werev November 24, 2020 at 6:36 pm #
    All young people have since quite a while back throbbed for appreciating you to live just and you were surprising. You would now have the choice to pass on that there are beautiful mail-order bride youths who will create you a unimaginable point of view that can assist you with living a shocking methodology. You will do different things together
  24. Henry Hubbard January 26, 2021 at 2:26 pm #
    Stunning teenagers who will commonly meet you on the site for dating. I think you need to use the site and find an adolescent who will change into your genuine appraisal. I envision that you could find a searing grown-up who will change into your adored one. I feel that you were available to living with your life accomplice


  1. Friday Flotsam | Bev Cooks - July 19, 2019 […] only pop in once a week for Friday Flotsams, I wanted to make sure you don’t miss my official book club post from yesterday. Lots and lots of you voted YAS, GURL to the series, so dunchew meez eet, […]
  2. Bev's Imaginary Book Club: Before We Were Yours, The Neighbors, and The Four Winds | Bev Cooks - March 11, 2021 […] here are The Other Book Club Posts, if you need something to do with your life […]

Leave a Reply